Os tibiale navicular refers to an extra bone found in the foot. An accessory bone is a bone that is not normally found in the average human, but in most cases is not considered abnormal. This condition represents a secondary ossification center (growth center) of the navicular bone. It is present from birth. The navicular bone is found on the inside part of the foot.
This condition has been observed in multiple family members and has propensity to occur slightly more in females than males. For most individuals this condition is a non-issue and most people who have them never have a problem with them. Over the years when x-raying patients for other problems I will point out that they have an extra bone in their foot and the usual response from the patient is nothing more than a yawn.
In an ideal situation, the navicular bone and the accessory bone will fuse together to form one bone. The problem that occurs is that sometimes the two bones do not fuse together and the patient is left with what is known as a fibrous union or basically a non solid union of bone to bone. This fibrous union is more like scar tissue and in theory can cause pain when excessive strain is placed upon it.
Adding to the drama is the fact that the accessory bone resides in the posterior tibial tendon. This tendon, by design, helps lift the arch of the foot so as you might expect there is a tremendous amount of tension on this tendon when a person ambulates. People with excessively flat feet tend to put more tension on this tendon and thus may be more prone to suffering pain from an accessory navicular.
WHAT CAUSES ACCESSORY NAVICULAR PAIN
Accessory navicular syndrome as it is called can result from a number of causes:
excess or overuse syndrome as seen in an athlete.
trauma to the foot as in an ankle sprain or direct trauma to the navicular bone.
chronic irritation from shoes rubbing against the extra bone, over time, may cause pain.
excessive pronation which strains the attachment of tibialis posterior muscles into the navicular bone.
Keep in mind, the larger the actual accessory bone, the greater the chance of it becoming an issue.
SYMPTOMS OF ACCESSORY NAVICULAR PAIN
Symptoms of this syndrome would include redness, swelling and tenderness over the navicular bone. The navicular bone is located on the inside of the foot approximately midway between the ankle bone and big toe joint. It will tend to be worse after activity and can be aggravated by those that wear very dressy shoes as opposed to casual shoes like sneakers. In other words, the flatter or less supportive the shoe, the greater the chance for pain.
DIAGNOSIS OF AN ACCESSORY NAVICULAR
Diagnosis is fairly simple based on an examination by your doctor. He or she will palpate the navicular bone, and based on the location of pain will suspect an accessory navicular. The doctor will also observe your gait to see if you are flatfooted. At this point an x-ray will make the definitive diagnosis.
Other causes of pain in the same area of the foot would include a fracture of the navicular bone or possibly tendonitis or even a partial tear of the tibialis posterior tendon that inserts into the navicular. In these cases there is usually a history of trauma.
People with a naturally "large" navicular bone may also develop a bursitis due to chronic shoe pressure.
ACCESSORY NAVICULAR TREATMENT
Treatment is broken down into conservative vs. surgical repair.
Most cases of accessory navicular syndrome may be treated conservatively with:
some sort of immobilization. This should allow the fibrous tissue between the two bones to heal. If a patient is extremely flat footed (pronated) then I lean more towards an orthotic than a boot as my main goal is to keep the patient's foot from flattening out too much and thus reduce the strain on the two bones.
supplementation with ice
oral anti-inflammatory medication.
If the patient is athletic sometimes we can keep them active with an orthotic, but other times they have to give up their sport for a period of time to allow the condition to heal.
If conservative care does not alleviate the problem then surgical intervention should be considered. The most common procedure for this condition is known as the Kidner procedure where a small incision is made over the navicular bone. The accessory navicular is identified and dissected free from the posterior tibial tendon. The posterior tibial tendon is then reattached to the remaining navicular bone.